How to Double-Track a Lead Vocal and Make It Sound Fuller Without a Mess
To double a lead vocal, record a second, separate take that copies the first one as closely as you can. Then keep it under the lead and trim its consonants and breaths so it mainly adds thickness on the held notes. To try it now, sing one chorus again on a new track. Then lower that track until the chorus sounds thicker but you can no longer hear two singers. The rest of this guide covers how to record a double that fits, how to clean it up, and how to place it so the mix stays clear. The numbers in the steps are starting points to try, not standards.
What makes a double sound full or messy
A double works because two performances are never quite the same. Small differences in timing and pitch make the voice sound thicker. When those differences get too big, the same thing turns into a mess. These are the usual causes:
- Consonants that land twice. An "s", "t" or "k" from the lead, followed a moment later by the same sound from the double, can sound like a stutter or a lisp.
- Breaths that stack. Two breaths before every phrase make the vocal sound noisy.
- Words that start or end at different times. A double that comes in late or holds a note longer than the lead draws attention to itself.
- A double that is too loud. Once it gets close to the lead's level, it stops sounding like one thicker voice and starts sounding like two singers.
- Different phrasing or vowels. If you sing "oh" on the lead and something closer to "aw" on the double, the two will not blend well.
One shortcut does not work. If you copy the lead track and play the copy alongside it, you just get a louder version of the same take. A double needs a real second performance.
How to record a double that fits
- Finish the lead first. Choose your final lead take, or put it together from the best parts, before you record any double. The double copies the lead, so if the lead changes later, the double has to be redone too.
- Listen to the lead while you sing. Put the finished lead in your headphones along with the backing track so you can match it word by word. Some singers find it easier with the lead a little louder than usual in the headphones.
- Copy your lead, not the original artist. Match your own phrasing, vowel shapes, vibrato and note lengths, even where you would sing the line differently today.
- Keep the same setup. Use the same microphone, the same spot in the room and the same distance. A double recorded with a different tone is harder to blend.
- Sing consonants and breaths softly. On the double, soften the "s" and "t" sounds and take quiet breaths. That leaves less to clean up later.
- Record one section at a time. Doubling one chorus at a time tends to give a closer match than singing the whole song in one pass. Record a few takes of each section and keep the one that follows the lead most closely.
- Decide where the doubles go. Doubles usually help most where the song needs to lift, such as the chorus or the last chorus. A verse often sounds more intimate with a single voice. You do not have to double the whole song.
How to clean up the double
Do these steps on the double only, and leave the lead as it is. Follow this order, because the level work in the next section comes after the EQ.
- Line up the starts and ends. Play the lead and the double together and listen to the first word of each phrase. If the double starts noticeably early or late, split it in your recording software and move that part until the starts line up. Then check the ends of held notes. If the double keeps going after the lead stops, shorten it or fade it out so both end together. Inside each word, small timing differences can stay. They are part of what makes it sound fuller.
- Remove or lower the breaths. Cut or silence the breaths on the double and keep only the lead's breaths. One breath per phrase sounds natural, and two tend to sound noisy.
- Tame the consonants. Find the sharp "s", "t", "k" and "ch" sounds on the double and either lower them or cut them out, so the lead carries them alone. Lowering them is often gentler than cutting, which can leave an audible gap. After a chorus is done, listen again: if the words still sound crisp, the lead is carrying the consonants well enough.
- EQ the double. The double does not need all of the lead's low end. As a starting point, try a low-cut filter on the double around 150 Hz. This keeps the low end from building up when two voices stack. If the double sounds brighter or hissier than the lead, a gentle cut in the top end can help it sit behind.
Setting the double's level and position
- Start low and bring it up. Play a chorus with only the lead, then add the double. As a starting point, set the double about 6 dB below the lead. Raise it slowly, and 1 dB at a time is a good step size to start with. Stop just before you start to hear two separate singers.
- Choose a placement. There are two common setups:
- One double in the center. This thickens the lead without making it wider, and it is usually the easier one to keep clean.
- Two doubles panned left and right. Record two separate doubles and pan them away from the center, with the lead staying in the middle. Try about 30% left and 30% right, then widen or narrow them by ear. Wider panning sounds bigger, but it can also make leftover consonants easier to hear because they come from the sides.
- Adjust the double's level where needed. Some lines may need the double lower, for example a quiet bridge, and some may need it a bit higher. You can also use volume changes to lower single consonants instead of cutting them. Where to do it (menu names can differ between versions):
- Audacity: choose the Envelope Tool on the Tools Toolbar, click the double's track to add control points, then drag them up or down. To change a whole phrase, select it, use Effect > Volume and Compression > Amplify, and type the gain in the Amplification (dB) box. Some effects in Audacity, such as filters and EQ, can remove a track's envelope, which is why the EQ step comes first.
- GarageBand (Mac): choose Mix > Show Automation (or press A), open the Automation Parameter pop-up menu in the double's track header and choose Volume fader. Click the curve to add points, then drag them up or down.
- REAPER: select the double's track and press V to show its Volume envelope. With the default mouse settings, Shift-click the envelope to add points and drag a segment up or down. To change a whole clip, drag the item's volume handle, the bar along the top edge of the item, up or down.
- Keep the effects shared. Send the double to the same reverb or echo as the lead rather than giving it a separate one, so both voices sound like they are in the same space. If the chorus starts to sound washy, lower the double's send before you touch the lead's.
Checking the result
- Mute and unmute the double. Loop a chorus and switch the double off and on. Without it, the chorus should feel thinner, not cleaner. If it sounds cleaner without the double, the double is too loud or needs more cleanup.
- Listen for the first and last words. Pay attention to where phrases begin and end. Those are the places where timing differences show most.
- Listen at low volume. Turn playback right down. The vocal should still sound like one voice. If you can pick out the double on its own, lower it.
- Take a break, then play the whole song. Ears get used to a sound quickly. After a rest, listen once from the start and fix only what you notice on that first pass.
When the double still sounds messy
- A held note wobbles or sounds sour. The double is probably slightly off pitch from the lead on that note. Re-sing that line, or lower or remove the double just there.
- One line will not line up. Removing the double for that line is often better than forcing it. A double that drops out briefly is rarely noticed.
- It sounds like a chorus of singers. Lower the double, or go back from two doubles to one.
- It sounds like nothing changed. Check that the double is a separate take and not a copy of the lead, then raise it a little.
A short checklist
- The lead was final before I recorded the double.
- The double is a separate performance with the same phrasing and vowels.
- Starts and ends of phrases line up.
- Breaths and hard consonants are removed or lowered on the double.
- I did the EQ on the double before adjusting its level by line.
- The double sits under the lead, and the chorus feels thinner without it.
- Both voices go to the same reverb or echo.
Want your doubles lined up with the lead for you?
KUBOMI, auto-mix and mastering for cover singers, takes over one part of this job: lining your doubles up with your lead. You can add your doubles as extra files alongside your lead and backing track, and KUBOMI tells the lead and the doubles apart (you can change it if one is wrong); the first version keeps your singing as it is while lining the doubles up with the lead. Recording a close double, deciding where to use it and listening to the result stay with you, so try one song with the doubles you already have.